BAYFIELD/MADELINE ISLAND REAL ESTATE SALES: AUGUST 2025

Four homes in the Bayfield area sold last month. 

In the city itself, just one, a condo on 2nd Street. It’s the third condo in that unit to have sold this year. It sold for $266,000. The others sold for $262,500 and $295,000. If you’re in the market for a condo in Bayfield, a few others are currently for sale.

Otherwise, a modest little house with five acres on N County J sold quickly and for $15,000 more than the sellers were asking. At $240,000, it’s a great price for a home—however modest—in the area. 

Nearby but on the other side of 13, another modest home, this a two bed, two bath house on 1.8 acres sold for $332,500—just under the area’s average sale price this year—after settling on the market for 50 days. Sellers initially sought $399,000 but ultimately settled for 83% of that.

Finally, a stunning home on 10 acres off Oak Ridge Heights, a home with sweeping views of the Apostle Islands and beyond, one with a carriage house and a bevy of high-end finishes, sold. It’d been on the market for 624 days. With an initial asking price of $1,999,000, it was never a property that was going to fly off the market, but with its unique features, it was bound to sell eventually. So, 1 and 3/4 years after hitting the market, the home sold for $1,193,251 (a strange figure), a price 60% of what the sellers initially sought. 

Landwise, a three acre parcel on Longwood Dr between the city and the golf course, sold for $18,576 an acre. A five acre parcel on Hwy 13 near Old Kennedy Rd sold for $11,693 an acre. 

Nothing on the island last month. 

VIDEO OF BAYFIELD / MADELINE ISLAND REAL ESTATE SALES, AUGUST 2025