BAYFIELD, WISCONSIN REAL ESTATE SALES: SEPTEMBER 2025.

Active September for real estate sales around Bayfield. 

Outside of town, a 2 bed, 3 bath cabin tucked in the trees off 13 near Turner Rd sold in six quick days for $463,000. It’s a pristine cabin replete with wood paneling, one that could use a few aesthetic updates, but if its purpose is simply that of a cabin, who cares. On nearly 8 acres, this could be a sweet little homestead. 

In Brickyard Creek, two more homes sold. One for $385,000 and another for $465,000. Brickyard Creek’s popularity cannot be understated--it’s downright competitive. Homes for sale there do not stay on the market for long; and they often sell above list price. Both of the properties that closed last month sold quickly and above sellers’ asking price. And both sold for cash. 

In town, three single family homes plus a condo sold. 

On the bend coming into town, 240 6th St S sold for $425,000. Great view, but nearly every car coming into and through Bayfield drives past the front of this home. This home was purchased in 2021 for $342,309. That’s a 19% increase. 

On S 4th St, a gorgeous home tucked in a copse of trees sold for $550,000. Between Rittenhouse and Manypenny, it’s situated so cleanly. From either street, the home’s discreet; and the surrounding trees buffer the home nicely from some of the city’s ambient noise. 

Only one other home in the city limits has sold for more this year: 129 N 1st St. 

Which also sold last month. N 1st has some of the best lake views in the city. This one does as well. It’s a great home. So many touches of warmth. A menagerie of interior styles, but good balance of colors and textures. And did I mention the view’s phenomenal. 

Also in town, a condo on N 2nd St. sold for $262,500. 

Landwise, a couple of golf course lots on Eagle Run sold. As well, a half acre on N 6th St sold for $40,000. Finally, in Brickyard, 1.6 acres on Creek Trail sold for $65,000. 

BAYFIELD, WISCONSIN REAL ESTATE SALES: SEPTEMBER 2025